Tenant screening is the single most important thing you do as a landlord. Get it right, and you avoid late payments, property damage, and costly evictions. Get it wrong, and you’re either stuck with a problem tenant or facing a fair housing complaint. Neither is fun.
The good news: you can be thorough and legal. Here’s how to screen tenants properly without crossing any lines.
Know What Fair Housing Actually Prohibits
The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on seven protected classes:
- Race
- Color
- National origin
- Religion
- Sex (including sexual orientation and gender identity, per recent HUD guidance)
- Familial status (families with children under 18, pregnant women)
- Disability
Many states and cities add additional protections — source of income, marital status, age, veteran status, criminal history, and more. Look up your local laws. Ignorance isn’t a defense.
The key principle: your screening criteria must be applied equally to every applicant, and those criteria must be based on legitimate business reasons — not personal preferences or gut feelings.
Establish Written Screening Criteria Before You List the Unit
This is where most small landlords go wrong. They wing it. They “just know” a good tenant when they see one. That approach is both unreliable and legally risky.
Before you advertise a vacancy, write down your screening criteria. Pin them to a document you can reference and, if necessary, show to an attorney or a fair housing investigator. Your criteria should include:
- Minimum income requirement: 2.5x to 3x monthly rent is standard.
- Credit score threshold: Decide on a minimum (e.g., 620) or specify what you’re looking for (no recent collections, no bankruptcies in the last 3 years).
- Rental history: How many years of positive rental history do you require? What counts as a red flag (prior eviction, broken lease)?
- Employment verification: Do you require current employment, or do you accept other verifiable income sources?
- Criminal background policy: More on this below — it’s a minefield.
Once these criteria exist on paper, apply them identically to every applicant. No exceptions for people you like. No extra scrutiny for people who make you uneasy.
Handle Criminal Background Checks Carefully
Blanket “no criminal history” policies are increasingly illegal in many jurisdictions, and HUD has taken the position that they can violate fair housing law due to disparate impact on certain protected classes.
Here’s a safer approach:
- Don’t ask about arrests. An arrest isn’t a conviction. It tells you almost nothing useful, and using arrest records is problematic under fair housing guidance.
- Focus on convictions, and be specific. Consider the nature of the offense, how recent it was, and whether it’s relevant to tenancy (drug manufacturing in a rental unit is relevant; a 15-year-old shoplifting charge is not).
- Do an individualized assessment. If a conviction comes up, give the applicant a chance to provide context — rehabilitation, circumstances, time elapsed. Document your reasoning for acceptance or denial.
- Check your local laws. Several cities and states have “ban the box” laws for housing that restrict when and how you can consider criminal history.
Whatever policy you adopt, write it down and apply it consistently.
Use a Consistent Application Process
Every adult who will live in the unit should fill out the same application. Use the same form every time. Collect the same documentation from everyone. Run the same background and credit checks through the same service.
Consistency is your best legal protection. If you’re ever challenged, you want to show a clear, repeatable process — not a patchwork of informal decisions.
A few practical tips:
- Use a written application that collects name, SSN (for credit check authorization), employment info, rental history, and references.
- Charge a reasonable, legally compliant application fee (check your state’s cap).
- Screen applicants in the order applications are received. “First qualified applicant” policies remove a lot of ambiguity.
Know What You Can’t Ask
During showings, phone calls, and interviews, landlords sometimes ask questions that feel like small talk but are actually fair housing violations. Avoid asking about:
- Where someone is “originally from” (national origin)
- Whether they have kids or plan to (familial status)
- What church they attend (religion)
- Whether they have a disability or need accommodations (disability — they’ll tell you if they need a reasonable accommodation)
- Their age or marital status
Stick to questions about their ability to meet the lease terms: income, rental history, move-in date, number of occupants. That’s it.
Document Everything and Send Proper Adverse Action Notices
If you deny an applicant, you need to know why — and so do they. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), if you deny someone based on information in a credit report or background check, you must provide an adverse action notice that includes:
- The name and contact info of the screening company you used
- A statement that the screening company didn’t make the decision
- Notice of the applicant’s right to dispute the report and get a free copy
Even when FCRA doesn’t technically require it, it’s smart to document your reason for denial. “Applicant’s income was $2,800/month; minimum required for this unit is $3,900/month” is clean and defensible. “Didn’t feel right” is not.
Keep your screening records for at least three to four years. If a complaint is filed, you’ll want that paper trail.
Proper tenant screening isn’t complicated, but it does require discipline. Write your criteria down, apply them the same way every time, document your decisions, and stay current on local fair housing rules. That combination protects your rental income and keeps you on the right side of the law.
Need a better way to track applicants, leases, and tenant records? Create a free DoorLedgers account and keep your landlord paperwork organized from day one.